Silk-y, Chocolate-y Goodness

Jane and I have become addicted to Silk's Light Chocolate Milk. We probably go through a half gallon every week or two. It's our "dessert." Someone even suggested to us that it makes a great hot chocolate, although it's been too hot to try it since we heard the suggestion. We've tried a whole slew of the silk products over the last 11 months, this is our favorite. (I really like the Silk Mocha beverage too.)

So we were in Whole Foods recently and they had a private-brand Soy Chocolate Soymilk product. It was $3.69 for a Ā½-gallon container. We pay $3.50 for the Light Silk at Ralph's. (Yes, that is the name of one of our grocery chains... if you don't believe me, google it!) We decided it was time for a taste test. We brought both containers home with us, and today was the day.

The winner was the Silk Brand Light Chocolate Milk, by far. We poured a glass of each. The Silk product was darker and thicker than the Whole Foods - 365 brand. It also had a more chocolate-y taste than the 365 brand, and a better overall mouth-feel. And it also won in the nutritional category, at least for the things we look at, although that may not be fair as the Silk Chocolate Soymilk we consume is the "Light" chocolate milk.

The nutritional information stacks up as follows (The Silk Light Chocolate Soymilk // 365-Brand Chocolate Soymilk):

  • 120 calories // 150 calories
  • 1.5 grams of fat // 3.5 grams of fat
  • 0 grams saturated fat // 0.5 grams saturated fat
  • 22 grams carbohydrate // 24 grams carbohydrate
  • 5 grams protein // 7 grams protein
  • 100 mg sodium // 170 mg sodium

So, as far as I'm concerned the 365-brand is okay, but if you can get the Silk Light Chocolate Soymilk, it's a better product. Jane actually disliked the 365-brand and wouldn't have it again.


  1. I haven’t hard choco soy milk in a long time but I guess the price thing is just the opposite as for regular soy milk: 1/2 gal of the 365 is about $2.99 while the Silk is closer to $4. I haven’t done a side-by-side taste test but the 365 brand tastes good to me. I also like the fact that the 365 comes in a recyclable container.

  2. My favorite personally is chocolate almond breeze – try it! i’ve never liked soy milk since i went to rice and almond milks, it has a strange taste. but that taste is usually covered up in the chocolate flavored anyway.
    Also, I do not buy Silk products because they’re owned by a dairy company unless I have absolutely no alternatives.

  3. Hi Sat,
    Yes, we liked the idea of the recyclable container. Perhaps that is something I’ll add to the letter I’ll be dashing off to Silk after Emily’s comment.

    Hi Emily,
    Wow, we had no idea that Silk is owned by a dairy company. That won’t stop us from purchasing the product however. We believe in supporting vegan options so they’ll become more mainstream… It’s the same reason we’ll buy vegan foods at non-vegan establishments. The more vegan products that are purchased, the more vegan products will become available…. However, I will be writing an email to Silk to extol them to move away from dairy for to ethical reasons.

  4. I understand that completely.
    It’s just that your money goes to a company that primarily gets their income from diary, but, I suppose it does show them the market/demand for soy milk if you purchase it from them.
    My main concern was that a few months back milk was found in containers of Silk chocolate soy milk… the thought of cross-contamination, yuck!

  5. Hi Emily,
    We missed the recall. That’s unfortunate. I poked around a bit to find out more about what happened. I didn’t find an answer, but did find this speculation:
    “They might not own their own equipment. So when Silk is not running their soy milk through the machine some other company that is dairy runs through the machine.”
    on the chowhound kosher board.
    I would guess that “other company” is likely to be their dairy product and someone didn’t follow proper cleaning protocols.
    The more I read about what these giant companies do to “produce” our food, the more I think we should eat nothing but whole foods. I’m not going to do that, but sometimes I’m tempted.

  6. silk totally rocks, i love everything i’ve ever tried from them. i like seeing a comparison made between brands, and i am relieved that silk won out in the end! great post….

  7. Hi QuarryGirl,
    Glad you enjoyed the post. I’m glad you’re happy with the products you’ve found. I understand the Silk Very Vanilla is supposed to be amazing, however, I haven’t seen the product anywhere, so I haven’t been able to try it.

  8. Even my dairy consuming husband loves silk chocolate soymilk…in fact, I don’t think I’ve come across anyone who doesn’t. My husband says it tastes like yohoo.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.